I bent the two tabs that go through the small holes and that allowed the light to sit more flush. I then just pushed the edging around the light towards the truck. I think another option would be to find some rubber trim it's a little taller and see if that helps. But the metal finish on mine...
Mine look way different than yours do. I'd give them a call and send them back. It looks like they forgot to metal finish them before sending them to the powder coater or something. I would not be happy with those.
I have the jeepsteel taillights. I didn't know they're not DOT approved. I noticed the side marker light does not blink. I wonder if that's the reason.
I did the Gladiator tailgate badges. I know there not for everyone, but I like them. I waited for them to finally come out with the color match stin-gray because I didn't want it to look to heavy with all black.
I did the same bumper this weekend. I put rigid lights that are backlight red that I tied to the running lights, then the white floods go to my switch panel. Actually found the bumper on walmat.com for 435.00