I've got the Tyger, works great as far as I'm concerned. Install was low effort, bed stays pretty much dry, and it's retained its shape very well.
I guess it depends on what you're aiming to put in the bed. I don't really store anything, just transport things. Plus I mainly wanted a low cost cover to simply keep the snow out of the bed in the wintertime.
I got the Tyger as well. Had them in the past and they are great quality and have an awesome warranty if anything ever happens. Looks pretty good, especially for the money!