Sponsored

23 Mojave manual to 23 Willys diesel swap. Level of crazy: 1-10?

Chaos Theory

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2023
Threads
17
Messages
260
Reaction score
510
Location
Eastern WA
Vehicle(s)
2023 Jeep Gladiator Mojave
Dear Abby, I've had my 23 Mojave for exactly a year. I've decided I really don't like the manual transmission in this Jeep, especially paired with the 3.6l engine. I've had 5 other stick shift vehicles (including 4WD) over my life and had no issues with them, so figured I'd get used to it. Despite regearing, I continue to fight the jankiness of the MT in this Gladiator, so much so that I had been considered getting a cheap little econo-box commuter vehicle to pair with the Jeep. Only recently did I rationalize what was happening, subconsciously-- I wanted to buy a 2nd car so that I could drive my 1st car less. That's a huge red flag. You should want to drive your Jeep, whenever and wherever.

I also went into the dealership yesterday to see what/if the clutch recall makes sense right now, or if I should wait. I was told I'd be charged for removing/reinstalling whatever mods interfere with the recall, which may get expensive due to my Artec full belly skid. What bothers me is that they didn't have a fix for almost 8 months, so it's not like I refused to get the recall work done before I added mods. I also don't believe the recall will do a thing to the performance of the clutch, and I've heard too many mixed reviews on aftermarket clutches to dump another $3k into that mod.

I love pretty much everything else about the Mojave. Rides great, awesome suspension, comfortable seats, decent styling. I bought a year ago, unfortunately just before the massive discounts. With the $20k+ in mods over the last year, I'm in for about $80k with 1 year now of massive depreciation. It's paid off, thanks to my trade-in and paid the difference in cash, so no loan to worry about.

The same dealership that wants to charge me to do their recall also happens to have a 2023 diesel Willys. I made the mistake of test driving it, and found out just how miserable my Mojave driving experience is compared to that. It was responsive, quick, no shifting, didn't throw any codes yet... It's also heavily discounted but lacks some major features, which explains why it's still sitting on the lot. Still, not many diesels left.

For shits and giggles I had them work up a trade value appraisal of my Mojave. Not really happy with how that turned out, but wasn't surprised. First-year depreciation is worst-case scenario. I'm prepared to take a money hit, but we're too far off right now. But if that Willys sits another month, they may reconsider.

Even if it were even swap (my loaded Mojave for near bare-bones Willy's) I'd have to spend another $25k to get it near what I have now (suspension, lift, tires, armor, etc).

I'm going to get a number of answers here, but on a scale of 1-10, what level of crazy would that be? Is Willy's trim worth dumping that kind of money or should I instead wait for the Gladiator 4XE next year, which appeals to me almost as much as the diesel (but will also cost a fortune).
Sponsored

 

Hootbro

Well-Known Member
First Name
Don
Joined
Apr 13, 2019
Threads
57
Messages
10,184
Reaction score
19,950
Location
Delaware
Vehicle(s)
2025 Gladiator Sport
7

At the end of the day you have to ask yourself if driving a vehicle you hate that is paid off, worth the expense of getting into something that is more enjoyable?

As to mods, I have bought my successive Gladiators without using them as trade at time of sale and briefly carried a note on the new vehicle and swapped my mods over and sold the old vehicle to Carmax at a later date. This was cheaper even without having a tax trade in credit. Like you, my vehicles are generally paid off. This would not necessarily work if carrying a bank note and less equity.
 

bleda2002

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 11, 2021
Threads
24
Messages
2,751
Reaction score
4,493
Location
34655
Vehicle(s)
2021 JTR Firecracker Red
How important are the features its missing? I've learned that buying the de-contented model typically means I end up hating it even faster if it doesnt have the options I actually enjoy/am used to.

Personally I'm waiting for the 4xe, I tried the diesel, it was better than the 3.6 but worse than my wife's JLU 4xe so it didnt really tickle me like I hoped it would. Sure its got a lot of torque, but the 4xe has more, and the extra HP of the 4xe is just a lot more engaging for me. And before the diesel cult jumps in, yes the diesel gets better MPG and I dont honestly care, I didnt buy the JT or JL for MPG's and 1-2 extra gas stops in 600 miles of road trip is not worth the ho hum performance to me.
 

JT1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2020
Threads
7
Messages
743
Reaction score
719
Location
Oklahoma
Vehicle(s)
2021 Gladiator Willys
If you're already contemplating losing a ton of value on a trade, toss another $1200 at the Mojave and put an ACT in it.
 

PuddleJumper

Well-Known Member
First Name
Cortlund
Joined
Jan 17, 2024
Threads
68
Messages
2,540
Reaction score
3,373
Location
Alexandria, Virginia
Vehicle(s)
23' JTM, 22' JTR, 22' F56S,
Build Thread
Link
Occupation
STACK Infrastructure Critical Operations Technician
Vehicle Showcase
1
just take the Mojave in for a 392 swap. it'll make it automatic and give you the power your looking for. Your already in the hole with mods you like. I'd just keep the ball rolling and make it exactly what you want rather than start over on run the odds of still hating it.
 

Sponsored

Libis22

Active Member
First Name
Libin
Joined
Oct 2, 2022
Threads
3
Messages
29
Reaction score
18
Location
Atlanta
Vehicle(s)
2015 Triumph Daytona 675R
Occupation
Software Developer
And I thought, I am the only crazy one.

I bought a 2023 Gladiator Mojave 6MT recently and been thinking about trading in for a diesel sport model as I am not completely satisfied with the 6MT. My hit is not as bad as I got the rebates but still stealerships are trying to low ball.. I also have a close to full optioned Mojave and sport/s I am looking at are barebones.

Things I observed.

I test drove diesel 2 times now both time not on highways and even though the response seems good compared to 3.6, it's not great. (may be I should have taken it on the highways :facepalm:) It feels like a lot of power trapped in there but not allowing to use it.. caged animal.. something along those sorts ? where as 3.6 MT is free but there is no power. 5-6 useless unless you are in perfectly flat roads and you have to rev it high to get any power- it takes some getting used to. Altogether, it's an okay driving experience.. every time I feel like I don't like driving it, I take it off-road and I remember I bought it in the first place.

6 MT clutch was bad when I first drove. Mine has the recall done, but I stalled multiple times and had a hard time learning the clutch engagement. I've driven manual cars other than 10 months of my 20 years of driving. But it got better with time with engagement but still power is meh. I also put a drop in K&N which kind of helped or it's my superstition. My next plan is a piggy back tune

If I were you and you are close to making this decision and lose a lot of money, I would try to test drive a ACT or CF clutch before doing recall. and if that feels good, do it locally and see if you get it reimbursed (not sure if you can do that now as Mopar has parts available). I cannot comment on previous clutch as I didn't drive JT/JL pre recall. Test driving a post recall manual also would help.

I decided against diesel as I never felt great in it. I have a diesel 5 MT Hyundai hatchback in India which also has VM motori engine which is my favorite car I ever owned. (Had a 2013 v8 mustang 6MT, JL 2.0) It is simple no emission stuff on it mated with a basic manual with a good clutch. Diesels now have too much stuff to go wrong and it kills the feel of driving too. Unless you live in a state you can delete all that, it wouldn't make sense to me. But of course if you think it's worth it, go for it!

I wanted LEDs, leather, cold weather, premium audio which I couldn't find on many diesels unless high end and I didn't want to buy something and then add options unless I do it myself. I am lacking time and skill for that so that also made that decision easier..

Also I watched these:





If I would go with the diesel I would get the longest extended warranty..

Waiting for 4XE is a good option so is the hurricane if that ever happens.

Did I confuse you enough?
 

wildtaco

Well-Known Member
First Name
Karol
Joined
Jan 4, 2023
Threads
13
Messages
446
Reaction score
760
Location
CT
Website
www.instagram.com
Vehicle(s)
23’ Diesel Rubicon Sarge Green
Build Thread
Link
Occupation
Engineer
just take the Mojave in for a 392 swap. it'll make it automatic and give you the power your looking for. Your already in the hole with mods you like. I'd just keep the ball rolling and make it exactly what you want rather than start over on run the odds of still hating it.
As an ecodiesel owner, I second this. Start a conversation with AMW 4x4, they'll get you squared away.
 

JW Jeep

Well-Known Member
First Name
John
Joined
Sep 10, 2022
Threads
25
Messages
238
Reaction score
224
Location
Colorado
Vehicle(s)
2022 Gladiator
Occupation
Retired
Wow I really don’t get this power thing ? My overland loaded with street tires and 3.6 8 speed runs great and I get 22- 23 mpg around town. I got a wild hair the other day and ran the glad pretty hard at every stop and wound her up to red line quite a few times. Even the people with me said this thing shits and gets for what it is ? !! I’ve owned many muscle cars, hot rods, speed boats and motorcycles and I don’t think it’s that bad. Sure it’s not a hellcat by any means but I can live with it and better then all the ford 5.4 Gm 350 dodge 4.7 pickups I’ve owned except maybe the 2 wheel drive chev 5.3
 

shokker70

Well-Known Member
First Name
Bryan
Joined
Dec 31, 2019
Threads
2
Messages
263
Reaction score
320
Location
Texas
Vehicle(s)
2022 Jeep Gladiator Texas Trail
Biggest loss for me going from the Mojave to a sport is the ride. I get it. We don't buy these things for ride quality. But I thought my girlfriend was gonna kill me. Mojave ride compared to a Sport with the Mopar lift is beyond night and day. Mojave was smooth! Not sure if it makes it worth trading, but I really enjoy the diesel over the 3.6
 
OP
OP
Chaos Theory

Chaos Theory

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2023
Threads
17
Messages
260
Reaction score
510
Location
Eastern WA
Vehicle(s)
2023 Jeep Gladiator Mojave
Biggest loss for me going from the Mojave to a sport is the ride. I get it. We don't buy these things for ride quality. But I thought my girlfriend was gonna kill me. Mojave ride compared to a Sport with the Mopar lift is beyond night and day. Mojave was smooth! Not sure if it makes it worth trading, but I really enjoy the diesel over the 3.6
This is my biggest concern... Trying to "buy" the Mojave suspension on a Willys will be an expensive gamble.

I appreciate everyone's comments. For clarification, I don't "hate" the manual, but it's disappointing. Is it a '$30k depreciation hit' disappointing? Nah. I guess not.

I'll probably pass on the Willys diesel and wait for the Gladiator hybrid-- but not model year 1. Maybe 2, or better 3 (so... 2026-27 if the model survives the sales slump?) In the meantime, I think I'll try the aftermarket clutch. The hurricane mod would be worth it if I thought I could keep this thing for another 8-10 years. With the amount of undercarriage rust I'm seeing after less than 1 year of light driving, I just don't see that happening.
 

Sponsored

Koolcarguy

Well-Known Member
First Name
Shane
Joined
Aug 8, 2021
Threads
2
Messages
507
Reaction score
680
Location
Colorado
Vehicle(s)
2021 Hydro blue Jt 2012 Gecko green Jk 2021 Gecko
Occupation
Car dealer
Dear Abby, I've had my 23 Mojave for exactly a year. I've decided I really don't like the manual transmission in this Jeep, especially paired with the 3.6l engine. I've had 5 other stick shift vehicles (including 4WD) over my life and had no issues with them, so figured I'd get used to it. Despite regearing, I continue to fight the jankiness of the MT in this Gladiator, so much so that I had been considered getting a cheap little econo-box commuter vehicle to pair with the Jeep. Only recently did I rationalize what was happening, subconsciously-- I wanted to buy a 2nd car so that I could drive my 1st car less. That's a huge red flag. You should want to drive your Jeep, whenever and wherever.

I also went into the dealership yesterday to see what/if the clutch recall makes sense right now, or if I should wait. I was told I'd be charged for removing/reinstalling whatever mods interfere with the recall, which may get expensive due to my Artec full belly skid. What bothers me is that they didn't have a fix for almost 8 months, so it's not like I refused to get the recall work done before I added mods. I also don't believe the recall will do a thing to the performance of the clutch, and I've heard too many mixed reviews on aftermarket clutches to dump another $3k into that mod.

I love pretty much everything else about the Mojave. Rides great, awesome suspension, comfortable seats, decent styling. I bought a year ago, unfortunately just before the massive discounts. With the $20k+ in mods over the last year, I'm in for about $80k with 1 year now of massive depreciation. It's paid off, thanks to my trade-in and paid the difference in cash, so no loan to worry about.

The same dealership that wants to charge me to do their recall also happens to have a 2023 diesel Willys. I made the mistake of test driving it, and found out just how miserable my Mojave driving experience is compared to that. It was responsive, quick, no shifting, didn't throw any codes yet... It's also heavily discounted but lacks some major features, which explains why it's still sitting on the lot. Still, not many diesels left.

For shits and giggles I had them work up a trade value appraisal of my Mojave. Not really happy with how that turned out, but wasn't surprised. First-year depreciation is worst-case scenario. I'm prepared to take a money hit, but we're too far off right now. But if that Willys sits another month, they may reconsider.

Even if it were even swap (my loaded Mojave for near bare-bones Willy's) I'd have to spend another $25k to get it near what I have now (suspension, lift, tires, armor, etc).

I'm going to get a number of answers here, but on a scale of 1-10, what level of crazy would that be? Is Willy's trim worth dumping that kind of money or should I instead wait for the Gladiator 4XE next year, which appeals to me almost as much as the diesel (but will also cost a fortune).
15 I own both not the Mojave but the 3.0 and the 3.6 there is no comparison the 3.0 out performs , better mileage, better offroad hands down guy's saying the "reliability " card haven't looked at the numbers compared to the 3.6. These diesels are awesome we have 210k miles combined on our 5 ecodiesel Jt's and Jl's ZERO ISSUES. Have you looked at the used Jt diesel market? There's not many out there guy's don't sell them after having one. These diesels value will continue to go up once there all gone every ecodiesel that Jeep has produced has give it time. The hybrid market has to many unanswered questions for me in the future especially resale....in the open dealer market they always bring less at auction just food for thought. I'd buy the diesel swap the mods then sell the Mojave. Good luck
 

Dafonte1968

New Member
First Name
Dante
Joined
Dec 12, 2023
Threads
0
Messages
4
Reaction score
5
Location
Mississippi
Vehicle(s)
2022 Gladiator
Occupation
FAA
I did the exact same thing, Traded a Texas edition with a stick for an Overland Diesel. Took a beating but worth it!!
 

69charged

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2023
Threads
12
Messages
292
Reaction score
335
Location
Manitoba
Vehicle(s)
23 JTRD
I would really look at the 392 swap. I have the diesel and love it. But I found the exact same vehicle as I have but with the 3.6. I test drove it and was like, nope. No way. But as I was waiting for mine I thought of the swap, and the wife was REALLY on board with it. If I ever go away from the diesel, it will be to a 392 swap.
Can you just imagine that sweet suspension paired with the power to back it up!!
What dreams are made of I tell ya!!!
 
OP
OP
Chaos Theory

Chaos Theory

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2023
Threads
17
Messages
260
Reaction score
510
Location
Eastern WA
Vehicle(s)
2023 Jeep Gladiator Mojave
I looked at the 392 swap. First of all, it's in Michigan, so in addition to $35k, it's a 2000 mile drive each way, and probably 8mpg once that engine is in. Plus 3-4 days hotel room while they're doing it. Couple extra thousand $ in addition

I also noticed the price doesn't cover any front suspension upgrades. That's a heavy engine, so likely additional cost.

It's just not practical for my rig. I can get all of that performance next year in a 4XE without the MPG hit. It won't sound as cool, admittedly.
 

Fly-by

Active Member
First Name
Jason
Joined
Oct 19, 2023
Threads
4
Messages
40
Reaction score
37
Location
Snoqualmie, WA
Vehicle(s)
2023 Jeep Gladiator Mojave 6MT
Occupation
Finance
Vehicle Showcase
1
You've already done an expensive mod by regearing. Depending the ratio you chose, you may need to regear the other way with the diesel.

I have a 2023 6mt Mojave. With 5.38s and the B&M short shifter it's really fun, despite the weird clutch. Just ordered a PCM today which will be sent to Livernois for an E85 tune.

An aftemarket clutch, tune, and short shift kit would come in around $3k. I would give this a shot before you end up $110k deep.
Sponsored

 
 







Top