DanW
Well-Known Member
- First Name
- Dan
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2017
- Threads
- 45
- Messages
- 1,866
- Reaction score
- 2,445
- Location
- Brownsburg, Indiana
- Vehicle(s)
- 21 JT Rubi, 18 JLU Rubi, 2008 JKU Rubi, 07 Vette
You can scoff and throw your opinions out there. But my experience contradicts what you imply. My opinion is that maybe you may have struggled to adapt to yours. Or yours had some kind of problem. Or you just don't like it and have a different opinion. I can respect that.We must have wildly different definitions of "spirited driving" and "off road" if you think the factory clutched and shift feel is acceptable. Glad its worked out for you though, and that you have a dealer competent enough to actually trust with replacing a clutch.....
I can also help you with the definition of spirited driving, too. It is not a Corvette. It's a Jeep. But it can be fun on twisty roads and the 3.6 loves to rev. When doing that kind of driving, I enjoy keeping it in it's power band. I don't baby it. Never have. And I frequently tow a boat because I like to fish. A lot.
Off roading? Well, I have over 30 years experience with 5 great Jeeps of my own. Everywhere from Moab to Jericho Mountain and many, many places in between, on all kinds of terrain.
Yes, I have a very competent dealership with a tech that knows what he's doing and of course, his own vehicles have been manual Wranglers. He did a new transmission and clutch on my JK at 96k miles and it was perfect. He did the JL clutch at close to 100k and again....perfect. Dude knows what he's doing. No squeaks, rattles, or strange noises of any kind and properly set up. From looking at the old clutch, it was in good shape. Plenty of friction material left....It looked good. Easily, according to his estimation, another 50k+ miles left in it. He said it was in better shape than any other he had replaced under the recall, including one that had less than 30k on it. Mine had the highest mileage of those he replaced, so he was impressed.
So my take on that is that in the hands of someone who knows how to properly drive a clutch, barring any defects, properly assembled at the factory, and properly installed and set up at Jeep assembly, this transmission/clutch can work very well.
And mine is one of the first batch of the production line, ordered days after the JL order Banks were open and delivered in January of 2018. It had no running updates, only three recalls and whatever they did during those. Mine was put into my Jeep when Jeep engineers were on the production line in Toledo alongside the factory workers, developing procedures, teaching, and learning. So the line had not reached full production rate yet....everything was assembled carefully, and inspected again in a holding lot by engineering and QC teams before transport to the dealership. The only problem I have had with that JL was delamination of the screen on the Infotainment system. Not bad for such an early example of a new model of ANY vehicle.
It's been an excellent clutch, transmission, and drive train. It was fine-tuned with a swap to 4.56 gears to be better matched to 35" tires and to make 6th gear functional. And it was lifted and put on 35's at 700 miles, so I can't even remember what it was like stock, because I barely drove it that way. I put the 4.56 gears at 48,250 miles, and it was a nice improvement in being able to pull 6th gear on more than flat land. It also made the crawl ratio in 1st gear/low range ridiculously good, I might add.
The only thing I would criticize about it is the ratio choices, mainly 3rd to 4th gear. That has never made sense to me, but I have adapted to it with no trouble.
Oh....I have 9 kids and have taught 8 of them plus one son-in-law to drive a manual. All of them do it more competently than most people I know who drive manuals.
Btw, the ONLY reason I bought an automatic in the Gladiator was for towing capacity. I happen to love the 8 speed auto, but would absolutely have bought a manual if the tow rating was equal to the auto.
Sponsored