Sponsored

The Replacement Theory

Lunentucker

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2022
Threads
247
Messages
5,875
Reaction score
15,385
Location
Virginia
Vehicle(s)
2021 Jeep Gladiator Mojave
Occupation
People Work?
I'm still perhaps months from making the jump to another platform, but I took a first baby step today.
The bride and I ventured out for lunch, and while in a bigger small town near home, I decided to start looking around.

2024 GMC Canyon AT4
Our first stop was a GMC trucks dealer.
As it happened, he had just unloaded a new 2024 Canyon AT4.
This one was in white, which is not likely to my color choice, but the color didn't matter much at this very early stage in the game.

Honestly, this was the lowest pressure most laid back car dealership I'd ever been in.
Family business established in 1961.
Zero dealer fees. No processing fee. No doc fee. Nothing. Interesting.


I told we'd like to drive one, but were in no way purchasing today.
He checked the fuel, and seeing that it was very nearly empty, took it to the other side of the building to gas up at their own pump on-site.
That's some old school stuff too around here.
He didn't even ask to see my license, but I did leave a nice Mojave as collateral.

First Impressions -
Visually, inside and out, the truck is great looking. I like the body lines, and even though I'd seen the interior online and thought it could be better, in 3D it looks great. Leather wrapped and soft plastics abound.
This one had the 20 inch wheels, which really fill the wheel wells nicely.

The Drive -
For a turbo 4, the exhaust is tuned nicely, and it has a little bit more growl and rumble than the stock Gladiator.
OOOPS!! All the way back is actually Low gear?!?!
That might take some getting used to. No wonder it wasn't shifting.
Once I caught the error and got it into drive, she goes!
310 HP and 430 pounds of torque make this little truck jump!
Road and wind noise were all but non-existent.
Road comfort and handling were perfect.
The stereo sounds great.
One thing I don't like is that the lights are all controlled from the screen. There is no physical switch, knob, or button.

We returned, talked a bit more, got his card, and left for our next stop.

___________________________________

2024 Toyota Tacoma TRD

The TRD was the highest trim level they had of the five trucks they had.

Again, not a likely color for me in the silver, but this was more about the drive.

First Impressions -
Visually, not as pleasing as the GMC, but a nice looking truck.
Inside was disappointing, with lots of cheap feeling plastics with hard corners and edges. The seats were comfortable, but didn't feel as nice as the GMC.

The Drive -
Another turbo 4 with decent pep, but clearly not as much as the Canyon.
278/265 felt less commanding.
The road ride was harsh. I questioned if they had the tires pumped up to 60 psi, because this thing was a wagon compared to the Mojave, and a Ben Hur chariot compared to the Canyon.
Cheap sounding sound system.

Summary -
GMC wins round 1 handily.
I loved my previous two Tacomas, but there's too much daylight between these two to ignore.

What's next?
Ranger
Stay tuned.

Jeep Gladiator The Replacement Theory 2024-canyon-overview-gallery-ext


Jeep Gladiator The Replacement Theory 2024-canyon-overview-gallery-int




Jeep Gladiator The Replacement Theory 7182ff35eced538cda236625fb741c7a


Jeep Gladiator The Replacement Theory TAC_MY24_0019_V001_r03IswlMTN_Ku55jdUnudgT80bii7QF5zdq47TY2B
Sponsored

 

Rusty PW

Well-Known Member
First Name
Russ
Joined
Jan 10, 2022
Threads
37
Messages
11,385
Reaction score
30,364
Location
Fayette Nam, Pennsyltucky
Website
www.youtube.com
Vehicle(s)
'22 JTRD, '11 370Z Nismo, '07 Honda VFR
Build Thread
Link
Occupation
Muff Diver
.

Jeep Gladiator The Replacement Theory Leavin
 

DailyMoparGuy

Well-Known Member
First Name
Gone
Joined
Mar 6, 2021
Threads
7
Messages
1,547
Reaction score
3,094
Location
Gone
Vehicle(s)
None
Occupation
Ghost Rider
Those GMCs are nice for sure. The Rangers are nice too but the front end looks kinda toy-ish. I don’t even know if that makes sense, but I don’t like the front end
 

Rusty PW

Well-Known Member
First Name
Russ
Joined
Jan 10, 2022
Threads
37
Messages
11,385
Reaction score
30,364
Location
Fayette Nam, Pennsyltucky
Website
www.youtube.com
Vehicle(s)
'22 JTRD, '11 370Z Nismo, '07 Honda VFR
Build Thread
Link
Occupation
Muff Diver
Makes one wonder why there's even a "Gladiator Versus" section at all, doesn't it?
Bless your heart.
I had to. It's the sarcasm in me.

Yea, I'm interested in your findings. And what other people see and feel about other trucks. I had looked at other trucks before I bought the JT. None of them really interested me at the time. What you post is any different from what I seen and felt.
 
Last edited:

Sponsored

Hootbro

Well-Known Member
First Name
Don
Joined
Apr 13, 2019
Threads
57
Messages
10,192
Reaction score
19,961
Location
Delaware
Vehicle(s)
2025 Gladiator Sport
Look forward to your take on the new Ranger. I sat in one of the newer Chevy Colorado's and just could not find a comfortable seating position with my 6'3" 275lb body size.
 

kevman65

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2020
Threads
51
Messages
3,879
Reaction score
5,756
Location
H
Vehicle(s)
J
This is my personal opinion, I hate mid-size trucks.

Only reason I'm in a JT IS because it's a Jeep.

I wanted a Scrambler back when I got out of high school. No one would finance a "kid" then.

So I said if Jeep ever came out with a truck version again I'd get it. It's bigger than the CJ7 I had, has all the "kool" factors of a Jeep. So bought it.

If/when I decide it's time to get back into a full sized truck it will probably be a Power Wagon if available.
 
OP
OP
Lunentucker

Lunentucker

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2022
Threads
247
Messages
5,875
Reaction score
15,385
Location
Virginia
Vehicle(s)
2021 Jeep Gladiator Mojave
Occupation
People Work?
Look forward to your take on the new Ranger. I sat in one of the newer Chevy Colorado's and just could not find a comfortable seating position with my 6'3" 275lb body size.
Yeah, you're a full sized truck fellow. They are noticeably more closed in feeling than the JT.
 

legacy_etu

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
May 19, 2021
Threads
3
Messages
1,448
Reaction score
1,792
Location
New England, USA
Vehicle(s)
23 Mojave, 25 Corvette Eray, 16 Wrangler UNLTD,
I'm still perhaps months from making the jump to another platform, but I took a first baby step today.
The bride and I ventured out for lunch, and while in a bigger small town near home, I decided to start looking around.

2024 GMC Canyon AT4
Our first stop was a GMC trucks dealer.
As it happened, he had just unloaded a new 2024 Canyon AT4.
This one was in white, which is not likely to my color choice, but the color didn't matter much at this very early stage in the game.

Honestly, this was the lowest pressure most laid back car dealership I'd ever been in.
Family business established in 1961.
Zero dealer fees. No processing fee. No doc fee. Nothing. Interesting.


I told we'd like to drive one, but were in no way purchasing today.
He checked the fuel, and seeing that it was very nearly empty, took it to the other side of the building to gas up at their own pump on-site.
That's some old school stuff too around here.
He didn't even ask to see my license, but I did leave a nice Mojave as collateral.

First Impressions -
Visually, inside and out, the truck is great looking. I like the body lines, and even though I'd seen the interior online and thought it could be better, in 3D it looks great. Leather wrapped and soft plastics abound.
This one had the 20 inch wheels, which really fill the wheel wells nicely.

The Drive -
For a turbo 4, the exhaust is tuned nicely, and it has a little bit more growl and rumble than the stock Gladiator.
OOOPS!! All the way back is actually Low gear?!?!
That might take some getting used to. No wonder it wasn't shifting.
Once I caught the error and got it into drive, she goes!
310 HP and 430 pounds of torque make this little truck jump!
Road and wind noise were all but non-existent.
Road comfort and handling were perfect.
The stereo sounds great.
One thing I don't like is that the lights are all controlled from the screen. There is no physical switch, knob, or button.

We returned, talked a bit more, got his card, and left for our next stop.

___________________________________

2024 Toyota Tacoma TRD

The TRD was the highest trim level they had of the five trucks they had.

Again, not a likely color for me in the silver, but this was more about the drive.

First Impressions -
Visually, not as pleasing as the GMC, but a nice looking truck.
Inside was disappointing, with lots of cheap feeling plastics with hard corners and edges. The seats were comfortable, but didn't feel as nice as the GMC.

The Drive -
Another turbo 4 with decent pep, but clearly not as much as the Canyon.
278/265 felt less commanding.
The road ride was harsh. I questioned if they had the tires pumped up to 60 psi, because this thing was a wagon compared to the Mojave, and a Ben Hur chariot compared to the Canyon.
Cheap sounding sound system.

Summary -
GMC wins round 1 handily.
I loved my previous two Tacomas, but there's too much daylight between these two to ignore.

What's next?
Ranger
Stay tuned.

2024-canyon-overview-gallery-ext.jpg


2024-canyon-overview-gallery-int.jpg




7182ff35eced538cda236625fb741c7a.jpg


TAC_MY24_0019_V001_r03IswlMTN_Ku55jdUnudgT80bii7QF5zdq47TY2B.jpg
Noooo, you can't go. Where will I get my daily sarcasm/meme fix?

Good honest reviews and they seem to sync with what other reviewers are saying. How was the tranny in the GMC? Responsive? That's one thing i LOVE about my Gladiator. The trans. is so responsive she kinda begs to be driven hard. If only she had another 50 ft/lbs and 30 hp.

Did you ever find out the tire pressures in the Taco? Was it that or does it just have a crap ride?
 

Sponsored

OP
OP
Lunentucker

Lunentucker

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2022
Threads
247
Messages
5,875
Reaction score
15,385
Location
Virginia
Vehicle(s)
2021 Jeep Gladiator Mojave
Occupation
People Work?
Noooo, you can't go. Where will I get my daily sarcasm/meme fix?

Good honest reviews and they seem to sync with what other reviewers are saying. How was the tranny in the GMC? Responsive? That's one thing i LOVE about my Gladiator. The trans. is so responsive she kinda begs to be driven hard. If only she had another 50 ft/lbs and 30 hp.

Did you ever find out the tire pressures in the Taco? Was it that or does it just have a crap ride?

The sales guy, he looked new, couldn't find it, but I suspect it was just harsh as built.
The GMC transmission seemed very responsive. The torque and the turbo response are simply incredible for a 2.7.
 

legacy_etu

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
May 19, 2021
Threads
3
Messages
1,448
Reaction score
1,792
Location
New England, USA
Vehicle(s)
23 Mojave, 25 Corvette Eray, 16 Wrangler UNLTD,
The sales guy, he looked new, couldn't find it, but I suspect it was just harsh as built.
The GMC transmission seemed very responsive. The torque and the turbo response are simply incredible for a 2.7.
Well that's good to hear. Yeah, I drove the new Silverado/GMC full size with the 2.7 turbo. It was fine around town power-wise but fell on it's face on the highway. Also, the trans. seemed a little slow to respond in the full size truck; hence my question. Sounds like they've improved it or it just works better in the midsize.
 

Lost1wing

Well-Known Member
First Name
Tim
Joined
Dec 22, 2020
Threads
24
Messages
2,611
Reaction score
2,866
Location
West Georgia
Vehicle(s)
2020 Jeep Gladiator Rubicon
Occupation
Retired AMT
This is my personal opinion, I hate mid-size trucks.

Only reason I'm in a JT IS because it's a Jeep.

I wanted a Scrambler back when I got out of high school. No one would finance a "kid" then.

So I said if Jeep ever came out with a truck version again I'd get it. It's bigger than the CJ7 I had, has all the "kool" factors of a Jeep. So bought it.

If/when I decide it's time to get back into a full sized truck it will probably be a Power Wagon if available.
Yes!
Sponsored

 
 







Top